Media Buying Briefing: ‘The golden age of audio’: New forms hit a higher note, but radio buyers still struggle to hear it

Illustration of a microphone next to a book that says 'Buy This Mattress.'

This Media Buying Briefing covers the latest in agency news and media buying for Digiday+ members and is distributed over email every Monday at 10 a.m. ET. More from the series →

For most of the last 15 years, radio has seen its total revenue either remain flat or drop slightly, until 2020 that is, when according to eMarketer, revenue plummeted 28 percent to $10 billion. That number is expected to stay about the same for the next few years.  

At the same time, digital audio continues to surge, forecast by eMarketer to hit $5.59 billion in 2021 after maintaining growth levels during the pandemic in 2020. Podcasting fueled much of that growth, as did continued expansion of digital audio streaming services like Spotify and Pandora, as well as newer platforms trying to muscle their way in. 

Rich Stern, CEO of TuneIn, a digital audio platform with 74 million listeners using content from traditional radio broadcasters like iHeart Radio as well as content from the NFL and CNN, said he believes “we’re in the golden age of audio.”

And Tony Mennuto, president of Wordsworth + Booth, the audio creative division of Horizon Media, agrees with the notion that audio is having its moment. “Look at TikTok, it would be nothing without audio, given how much music is driving its use.”

Updates to the medium have been long overdue, which contributed to radio’s overall stagnation from a revenue standpoint. “We’re trying to reinvent radio for a digital world,” Stern said. “We’re not changing the medium of radio, because people love it. We’re changing the distribution and monetization — and bringing it in line with the real scale of global digital from a platform perspective. This has been the missing piece for the industry for a long time.”  

Specifically, podcasting offers the most significant momentum among the newer players. One of its appeals is the embedded nature of the advertising, most often read by hosts (although that’s also a limitation, but more on that later). What it’s missing is some of the back-office elements that make it more measurable and usable among buyers and planners, along with a lack of scale. That’s where companies like Backtracks come in. 

“If you heard an ad about tennis racket technology in a podcast about tennis, it’s not out of place — it’s probably of interest to the listener,” said Jonathan Gill, CEO of Backtracks, a tech platform for podcasting advertising and analytics that recently got certified by the IAB Tech Lab. “It’s contextually relevant.” Gill said he’s heard of podcasts that tried removing all advertising, but were forced to put them back in after listener complaints about their absence. 

“With the introduction of time shifting of audio, specifically on the ad side, when an advertiser can go from a more survey-based methodology of counting that’s not as accurate, to something that’s both more accurate and precise, they get the trifecta of better data, cheaper ad spend and more capabilities of targeting,” Gill said. 

As hot as they are, podcasts need to advance how to offer new ad possibilities, beyond hosts reading marketing messages, which isn’t easily scalable. “Treat advertiser-provided and host-read ads more uniformly, where an advertiser can choose what’s best for them, and it’s easier for the publisher to approve and set up,” Gill added. 

Meanwhile, terrestrial radio is doing all it can to become more digital-first. But that part of the industry finds itself caught between its shrinking traditional base (which is heavily reliant on local advertising) and its transition to digital add-ons like mobile apps.

“If you look at what’s happening in audio right now, it’s a bit of a tale of two cities,” said TuneIn’s Stern. “Think about podcasting, which has a lot of listening and engagement, but has a very nascent monetary infrastructure for advertisers. That’s versus radio, which really understands the frequency and reach of carrying those messages, but struggles to aggregate enough listening on their platforms.”   

“If you talk to a media buyer, they’ll tell you they’re still figuring it out,” he added. “There’s still some catching up to do. The people that were buying traditional radio are not the same buyers looking for digital audio.”

Planners and marketers “still think of audio as an after-thought of sorts behind TV and [other] digital [options],” said W+B’s Mennuto. “One of the biggest problems is they don’t know how to use the medium. Many just repurpose TV content, while others don’t use the time wisely. But if you do it right, you can connect on such a deep emotional level. And remember, radio still reaches more than 90 percent of the country — and that’s mostly millennials.” 

Color by numbers

If there were any doubts that legalized sports betting has practically taken over live sports on television, AdImpact has erased them. The ad tracking SaaS platform analyzed week one of the NFL season and found that sports betting ads appeared 6,500 times across the various telecasts—with FanDuel alone appearing 1,500 times.

The single largest ad category that was advertised in week one was fast food, which ran 14,000 ads. And the single advertiser with the most ad appearances was insurance firm Geico, at just under 4,000.

Takeoff & landing

  • Omnicom consolidated its control over Mercedes Benz’s media, creative and performance-marketing duties last week, forming a new unit called TeamX to handle all that work. Publicis lost its digital duties in the consolidation. Omnicom tapped two German agencies, digital shops Antoni and PR agency OSK, to help serve the German carmaker. 
  • Havas Media Group Canada hired Peter Papageorgiou as vp of digital solutions & performance, coming from CIBC as head of audience; and Elizabeth Lem as vp and managing director/head of MX Development, who was most recently managing director at GroupM’s m/SIX. Both will report to new Canada president Noah Vardon.
  • Comcast’s Freewheel unit, which houses its Strata platform and serves as a backbone to all of Comcast’s streaming efforts, partnered with connected TV agency Strategus to incorporate the latter’s CTV inventory into Strata’s offering. 

Direct quote

“New York used to be able to sell itself as being the center of everyone. Writers, storytellers, photographers, all would come here to be ‘in the mix. But the mix is now online, with less in-person events or coffees … New York needs to sell the ability to connect with a diverse talent pool, critical for these industries to continue to grow. That is what makes New York unique and powerful.”

— Steven Rosenbaum, executive director of the New York Media Lab, about the city’s ability to maintain its status as a global media and tech hub.

Speed reading

  • Digiday senior news editor Seb Joseph assembled a handy and definitive guide to what’s happening in privacy, arguably the most important issue in advertising and media today — even if many companies spend as much effort avoiding the hot topic. 
  • Digiday’s senior editor of research and features Max Willens dissects Facebook’s proposed solution to marketers for its measurement issues: just spend more money with us seems to be the crux.  
  • Variety wrote about Nielsen’s decision to transition from delivering TV ratings to impressions for local TV starting January 2022, perhaps in a bid to distract from its recent de-accreditation by the Media Rating Council.

More in Media

NewFronts Briefing: Samsung, Condé Nast, Roku focus presentations on new ad formats and category-specific inventory

Day two of IAB’s NewFronts featured presentations from Samsung, Condé Nast and Roku, highlighting new partnerships, ad formats and inventory, as well as new AI capabilities.

The Athletic to raise ad prices as it paces to hit 3 million newsletter subscribers

The New York Times’ sports site The Athletic is about to hit 3 million total newsletter subscribers. It plans to raise ad prices as as a result of this nearly 20% year over year increase.

NewFronts Briefing: Google, Vizio and news publishers pitch marketers with new ad offerings and range of content categories

Day one of the 2024 IAB NewFronts featured presentations from Google and Vizio, as well as a spotlight on news publishers.