Cyber Week Sale:

Save 50% on a 3-month Digiday+ membership. Ends Dec 5.

SUBSCRIBE

Bleacher Report CEO: Sites with a casual audience are ‘dead’

Already, 2017 is shaping up to be the year of devotion.

Last year digital properties wowed with big numbers on social platforms, but the name of the game now is loyalty, according to Dave Finocchio, CEO of Bleacher Report, who was the guest of this week’s Digiday Podcast.

“Sites that have honest-to-God fans and loyal readers will be fine. Sites that grew up with passers-by readers are dead. They’re dead. My take is if all you are is a site people spin through a couple times a month and you’re monetizing them with display or Outbrain or whatever, a couple years from now you’re dead. If you have real fans and you can get brands integrated, you’ll be fine.”

Below are more highlights from the episode:

Bleacher Report was founded to make sports media fun again
“Sports was getting to the point where it wasn’t entertaining enough. At the end of the day, sports is entertainment and market wasn’t celebrating that. There wasn’t social content. There were a lot of long articles and diatribes.”

Bleacher Report wants to be a “lifestyle brand” for young males
“If you look at the male millennial space, there are not brands that are influencing that generation at scale and shaping the behavior of those consumers. Sports is the best to do that. Sports is the only category where men content about on a consistent basis.”

TV advertising during games won’t reach young sports fans
“If you’re on TV, do you think young people are sitting and watching the commercials? Um, no. Are there less young people watching the game to begin with? Of course, yes.”

The way to compete with the duopoly is differentiation
“They’re going to be totally transactional. Everybody buys the same products off the shelf. If they’re just doing that, we all know when you’re flipping through your Facebook feed you’re not stopping and looking at too many of the commercials that run. If you’re big enough in the content space and you’re able to weave brands very cleverly into content that people are sharing organically, that’s what we have. That’s offering something to an advertiser, for a male millennial demo, that they really can’t get anywhere else.”

Facebook is often not being evil, just disorganized
“They’re less machiavellian than people think, and sometimes they’re just being disorganized. They have competing interests. We’re pretty patient. A lot of people think there’s some evil plan in place. I don’t think there is. There’s an ad sales team in charge of driving revenue, and there’s a media team that’s trying to help publishers. They’re trying to figure it out.”

More in Media

Digiday+ Research Subscription Index 2025: Subscription strategies from Bloomberg, The New York Times, Vox and others

Digiday’s third annual Subscription Index examines and measures publishers’ subscription strategies to identify common approaches and key tactics among Bloomberg, The New York Times, Vox and others.

From lawsuits to lobbying: How publishers are fighting AI

We may be closing out 2025, but publishers aren’t retreating from the battle of AI search — some are escalating it, and they expect the fight to stretch deep into 2026. 

Media Briefing: Publishers turn to vertical video to compete with creators and grow ad revenue in 2026

Publishers add vertical video feeds to their sites to boost engagement, attract video ad spend and compete with news creators.