Save 50% on a 3-month Digiday+ membership. Ends Dec 5.
It used to be that Internet giants fought on the terms of who had the most eyeballs. Nowadays, it’s all about the data: amassing it, crunching it, using it for services and advertising, all without crossing the line. Where that line is depends on who you ask. The general rule of thumb seems to be “don’t surprise your users.” But that runs up against the cardinal dictum of Silicon Valley: Keep innovating or die. David Berkowitz, senior director of emerging media and innovation at digital shop 360i, senses two Internet giants, Google and Facebook, have crossed the line. He dings Google for favoring its social data in search results while Facebook is on the hook for crunching user social information as part of a publishing partnership with Politico. Here’s his take:
In each of these examples, the offending party is being accused of violating the Covenant that was formed between the People and the Chosen Media. It’s a Covenant that says transparency, privacy, and authenticity are sacred. It’s a Covenant that says the People own the Chosen Media, no matter which corporations participate. It’s a Covenant that says that the People’s loyalties are to the Chosen Media, and to each other; everything else is fluid. Few other things are sacred anymore. The prophets of Lucy and Berle and Cosby no longer carry the same resonance. Newer idols, like “American Idol,” work precisely because they resonate through the Chosen Media. In lieu of temple chambers, we have echo chambers. What’s sacred today may not be tomorrow. Yet right now, media companies, marketers, and everyone else must respect the Covenant between the People and the Chosen Media — or face the uproar by those aggrieved.
Read Berkowitz’s full post on his blog, The Marketers Studio. Follow him on Twitter at @dberkowitz.
More in Media
What publishers are wishing for this holiday season: End AI scraping and determine AI-powered audience value
Publishers want a fair, structured, regulated AI environment and they also want to define what the next decade of audience metrics looks like.
Digiday+ Research Subscription Index 2025: Subscription strategies from Bloomberg, The New York Times, Vox and others
Digiday’s third annual Subscription Index examines and measures publishers’ subscription strategies to identify common approaches and key tactics among Bloomberg, The New York Times, Vox and others.
From lawsuits to lobbying: How publishers are fighting AI
We may be closing out 2025, but publishers aren’t retreating from the battle of AI search — some are escalating it, and they expect the fight to stretch deep into 2026.
Ad position: web_bfu