‘It can’t be optimized’: Agency buyers see comScore’s value diminishing

It’s a tale as old as digital media: Publishers don’t like comScore traffic metrics. Most of the time, comScore traffic is lower than publishers’ own internal metrics. Some call it the comScore haircut.

Now, for buyers, who have more tools available than before and have more digital media buys designed for direct-response, its value as a way to decide what websites to spend money on may be diminishing.

ComScore audience data is primarily used for media planning and buying, content-category classifications and a market-level view of the competitive landscape around publishers and audience buys. ComScore acts, it says, in the best interests of both publishers and agencies — on behalf of their advertisers.

“We’re the referees. Our business is being predicated on being trusted by both sides. Our incentive is to get it right,” said Andrew Lipsman, vp of marketing and insights, who said that it is one of the only ways buyers can get duplicated measurement of audiences across platforms, including desktop, mobile, app or the mobile web.

Perhaps feeling the mounting ambivalence, the platform is forcing itself to evolve: In February, comScore acquired Rentrak, a media measurement platform for movies and TV, which is promising to buyers with clients looking for cross-channel buys and could potentially mean a new growth opportunity for the company.

Lipsman said that comScore’s value hasn’t diminished and provides a holistic view that helps planners understand a buy. One challenge for comScore is in it doesn’t provide desktop measurement globally on a syndicated basis — which is one reason the Business Insiders of the world claim it’s skewed. (It does provide it on a publisher basis if it’s asked for.)

As the platformification of the media industry continues, publishers say that reach on social platforms, especially Facebook, can’t be ignored. “ComScore’s methodology follows the marketplace,” said Ben Winkler, chief investment officer at OMD. “It can’t be optimized for the latest distribution strategies. So publishers who have most aggressively embraced social distribution will be undercounted – for now.”

From Business Insider to BuzzFeed, every publisher has at some point disputed the numbers comScore puts out. Earlier in the month, Business Insider said it disagrees with comScore estimates that put its reach at 100 million, while it said its own figures showed an audience of over 300 million. BuzzFeed said the same earlier in the year. The gap between comScore figures and publishers’ internal metrics can be as high as threefold, which muddies the water for media buyers looking for traffic thresholds to place brand buys.

Advertisers and their agencies don’t transact just using comScore numbers; it’s usually used as just one tool in the mix. For brand campaigns — not direct-response buys — comScore’s VCE, or validated campaign essentials tool, can be used to make sure brands are getting the right audience via targeting.

At the same time, buyers can’t rely on publishers’ own numbers, which is tantamount to students grading their own homework: Everyone gets an A.

A former publisher who declined to be named said that for him, comScore is now less relevant because niche publishers have other, more sophisticated measurement tools. For the most part, audiences that advertisers care about can be found at scale only on platforms like Facebook. Direct deals are diminishing, which makes individual unique visit data meaningless.

For media buyers, however, comScore’s relevance is in decline. Greg Pomaro, head of media at Mediasmith, said that in general, the reporting part of comScore, which tells buyers which sites are good choices to buy for specific audiences, is becoming less critical for him. That’s for a few reasons: There are other tools, like MRI, and a lot of digital media buyers are designed for direct response, not for “brand.” So campaign performance data becomes more important than the upfront “planning.” 

“You can afford to take some chances and be a bit less fussy about what sites you start your campaign with since the performance data will prove their value, or lack of value, and you optimize around them,” said Pomaro. 

Where comScore does remain relevant is as an audience-validation tool. For example, Pomaro was working with a client for a branding and identity campaign — where the response had nothing to do with clicks — that needed to target moms with kids. He found a bunch of websites that should have worked but, via comScore, found that they were delivering men. The sites were kicked off the plan.

The programmatic trend also serves more direct-response goals than money going to “brand” campaigns. Once that changes, comScore regains its relevance as an upfront planning aid, said Pamaro. “As digital media becomes more programmatic, comScore’s value becomes more niche. It’ll be their challenge to adapt,” said Winkler.


More in Marketing

What TikTok’s e-commerce launch could mean for marketers and content creators

TikTok has officially launched its new e-commerce platform, TikTok Shop, earlier this month on August 1. Using the new e-commerce platform, brands and creators can sell products directly on the platform, potentially creating new revenue streams, and tap into the short-form video platform’s growing popularity.

‘The influencer industry can be really vile’: Confessions of an influencer marketer on the industry’s unfair hiring practices

While the influencer industry might sound exciting and like it’s full of opportunities, one marketer can vouch for the horrific scenarios that still take place behind the scenes.

Digiday+ Research: Marketers said revenue grew in the last year, with more growth expected ahead

After a tumultuous 12 months, marketers are getting a clear picture of how they really did during a time of true uncertainty. And, as it turns out, it wasn’t all that bad.