‘We’re creating inventory faster than they can fill it’: Publishers see YouTube ad prices drop 20%

YouTube has seen coronavirus news videos soar in popularity over the past month. But — surprise, surprise — ad revenue hasn’t keep up for the publishers producing the videos.

Sources at two different publishers said YouTube CPMs had fallen more than 20% from highs recorded earlier in 2020, and they were bracing for the possibility that declines could deepen as the year wears on.

A source at a third publisher said that while CPMs had dropped, low ad fill rates on their coronavirus content presented a bigger problem. “The fill rate is nowhere near what it could be,” said that source, who refused to share a specific ad fill rate for their coronavirus videos. “We’re creating inventory faster than they can fill it.”

This is a story playing out beyond YouTube. Programmatic ad rates, according to a variety of publishers, are down over 30%. Beyond keyword blocking, the nearly halted global economy simply doesn’t have as much ad demand. Witness Google and Facebook themselves seeing severe declines in its own ad rates. This inevitably filters down to publishers.

“What we’re seeing on YouTube is what we’re seeing across Facebook, Twitter, elsewhere,” the second publishing source said. “We’re seeing record engagement but that’s not correlating to ad dollars coming in.”

At the beginning of February, before the spread of coronavirus had begun to accelerate in the United States, YouTube instituted a policy that made content related to the disease ineligible for monetization on its platform. 

Last month, YouTube announced it had reversed that policy, with some exceptions: videos that spread misinformation, for example, or challenge-style videos that had the potential to spread the disease, would remain ineligible.  

On some level, YouTube’s reversal came at an opportune time. While digital video consumption has been strong across many categories over the past month, news and entertainment were the categories that saw the sharpest increases in engagement across digital video platforms, according to Tubular Labs CEO Rob Gabel.

From March 11to April 14, 30% of the videos uploaded to YouTube by news publishers were coronavirus-related, and those videos generated over 40% of the views those publishers tallied, according to Tubular Labs data.

For top news publishers, those gains were especially strong. For example, nearly 15% of the 1.4 billion views NBC News has racked up on YouTube over the past 14 years have come in just the past month, according to Tubular Labs data.

“The numbers we’re seeing right now are numbers we haven’t seen in years,” that second publisher source said.

Yet that engagement has not attracted advertiser interest. The revenue declines on YouTube are similar to those that publishers have seen on written coronavirus coverage: Coronavirus stories yield about 30% less revenue than stories about something else, multiple revenue leaders at media companies told Digiday last week.

The issue with news is part of a larger story of declining ad revenues across digital media. The IAB reported that ad spending declined about 33% in March, and platforms including Facebook and Google reported that they were expecting advertising rates to decline.

YouTube has made some recent efforts to goose demand; this week, it unveiled a tool designed to help small businesses create video ads for its platform.

“This is about the long game,” the second source said. “If we continue to be a trusted source of news for our audience, they’ll continue to be there for us on the other end.”


More in Media

YouTube is under fire again, this time over child protection

Adalytics Research asks, ‘Are YouTube advertisers inadvertently harvesting data from millions of children?’

Illustration of a puzzle that spells out the word 'media.'

Media Briefing: Publishers pump up per-subscriber revenue amid ad revenue declines

Publishers’ Q2 earnings reveal digital advertising is still in a tight spot, but digital subscriptions are picking up steam.

Lessons for AI from the ad-tech era: ‘We’re living in a memory-less world’

Experts reflect how the failures of social media and online advertising can help the industry improve the next era of innovation.